"What saves this from being a failure of a movie is John Woo's expert directing and his uncanny knack to create amazing action scenes."
- James H.
Broken Arrow (1996)
Director: John Woo
Producer: Bill Badalato, Terence Chang, John Follmer (supervising), Joe Gareri (executive), Christopher Godsick (executive), Mark Gordon (II), Brad Lewis (executive), Dwight H. Little (executive), Michelle Maples (executive) Gary Maxwell, (line) Allison Lyon Segan (co-producer)
Writer: Graham Yost
Cast: John Travolta, Christian Slater, Samantha Mathis, Delroy Lindo, Bob Gunton, Frank Whaley, Howie Long
Running Time: 108 min.
Plot: Two military pilots (Travolta and Slater) engage in a no-holds-barred battle against time and each other in a race to recover two stolen nuclear warheads. When a B-3 Stealth Bomber crashes in the Utah desert during a top-secret test run, the military quickly moves in to retrieve its two "broken arrows." But the situation spins wildly out of control after one of the pilots reveals the crash to be part of an incredible nuclear extortion plot.
RYAN LUNDGREN'S REVIEW: Very absurd but very amusing. John Woo has done the impossible - he takes a tired plot and gives it some new life as Travolta steals nuclear bombs on the air craft and tosses Slater of the plane. The reason is because Travolta has been past up for promotions and he wants to retire. It doesn't clearly explain, but that doesn't prevent Woo from creating an "above average" action film. There isn't a lot of Woo's specialty but he is, no doubt an ace at making arousing, jaw-dropping action scenes. The acting is pretty good, and Woo makes Slater into an action star. Travolta has calmness to his villain role making him excellent. Mathis isn't a damsel in distress but she's tough and Interesting. Though Broken Arrow has only 3 gun fights, John Woo somehow holds our attention. I didn't like Broken Arrow the first time I saw it, I thought it was dumb, but then I saw it again and I really liked it.
RYAN LUNDGREN'S RATING: 7/10
NUMSKULL'S REVIEW: The John Woo Movie That Is Not A John Woo Movie.
The maestro of mayhem served as director and is credited as such, but he had to provie he could turn out a commercially viable, no-frills action flick without getting too violent or stylish for American audiences.
And it worked. Broken Arrow is a strong film on all fronts if it's mindless, Hollywooden action you seek. The story is kinda bland but not laughably so, the thrills 'n' spills are satisfactory but not overly explicit, and the acting, while far from great, is sufficient rather than flat-out bad (except for Howie Long...which begs the query: which is worse, retired football players in supporting roles or basketball stars with whole movies built around them?...Never mind, stupid question.).
John Travolta is pissed off that he's not advancing on the U.S. Air Force chain of command, so he steals a thermonuclear device and threatens to blow shit up with it. His former buddy Christian Slater, the token plucky female (Samantha Mathis) and a pencil-pusher (Frank Whaley, who starred with Kevin Spacey in SWIMMING WITH SHARKS, a personal favorite of mine) have to stop him. Sound simple enough? It damn well ought to.
There's nothing here to blow you mind, but nothing to numb your skull with boredom either. It's far superior to the butchered version of Hard Target that was shown in U.S. theaters. It can be seen as John Woo trying his hand at an Americanized action flick or as John Woo hacking out an unremarkable product to prove his capabilities, depending on your stance, but either way, it's reasonably solid.
NUMSKULL'S RATING: 6/10
JAMES H'S REVIEW: The ideas behind "Broken Arrow" are simple ones. They borrow elements from other movies. The plot? Essentially the plot is the same as "Thunderball". You remember "Thunderball" don't you? The bad guys steal two nuclear warheads and demand money, or they blow some shit up. The film also borrows from "Speed". What a coincidence, Graham Yost, writer of "Speed", also wrote this. There's a little lack of creativity on his part. As well as certain plot devices, it also borrows certain situations, and essentially the same characters from "Speed".
That's not to say it's a bad movie. John Travolta really digs in and has fun as Deakins, the pilot who has been passed over for promotion too many times, he's flipped his lid. Christian Slater isn't bad either, he still doesn't have that screen presence to pull of a good action hero though. Samantha Mathis plays a park ranger, who is pretty much the same as Sandra Bullock's character from "Speed".
What saves this from being a failure of a movie is John Woo's expert directing and his uncanny knack to create amazing action scenes. The highlight of the action is the shootout in the mine. The finale on the train is pretty damn cool, but it seems a little too hokey and preposterous.
"Broken Arrow" is quite the good action film despite its flaws, and it does rank higher than some other of John Woo's American films ("Hard Target", "Blackjack"). It's the kind of movie to watch with the volume up (especially on DVD).
JAMES H'S RATING: 7/10